Joining a MAT: what schools should know before making the move
Feature
Teachers in a meeting

With increasing numbers of schools considering academy conversion and joining existing multi-academy trusts (MATs), deciding whether (and which) trust to join is one of the biggest strategic decisions. Tina Morris, a director in the education team at law firm Schofield Sweeney provides advice on what schools should consider before making the move

Whether due to financial pressures, government policy or the sheer appeal of access to better resources, an increasing number of schools are exploring the possibility of converting to academy status and joining a multi-academy trust (MAT).

Enticed by potential benefits such as access to stronger leadership, teaching practices, curriculum development and school improvement support, as well as specialist expertise in areas such as SEND and safeguarding, it is easy to see why such a move is appealing. There are also opportunities to share costs for functions such as HR, payroll, IT and legal services providing greater financial and operational resilience. As the support offered to schools from the ever-depleting resources within local authorities declines, these advantages can be increasingly attractive.

But there are some disadvantages that this transformation can bring too which must be fully understood, most notably a loss of independence, and schools must give thorough consideration to those implications and carry out extensive due diligence before making a commitment.

Joining a MAT is a long-term strategic

decision and should be considered as such. School leaders and governors should ensure that the move supports the schools’ long-term vision and priorities and, most importantly, will improve the standard of education pupils receive.

The educational philosophy, approach to the curriculum and general values, culture and ethos of the MAT should be aligned with those of the schools’, and leaders should consider its reputation, perception among parents, staff and the local community, and its track record when it comes to educational standards and results.

Alongside these strategic considerations, if the MAT is considered a good fit, there are a number of legal and practical issues that schools will need to address. Seeking legal advice early in the process will help schools navigate the due diligence process, identifying potential complications at the outset to avoid delays and ensure the transition runs as smoothly as possible.

Governance and Independence

The first factor to consider is governance and independence. One of the biggest changes when a maintained school converts to academy status and joins a MAT, is the transfer of responsibility from the school’s governing body to the academy trust board.

Schools need to understand what this will mean in practice, particularly in terms of how much independence they will retain and who will be responsible for making decisions.

While schools may continue to have local governing bodies, the powers delegated to them can vary considerably between trusts. The arrangements should be clearly documented through a scheme of delegation, which sets out which decisions are made by the trust board, its leadership team and individual schools.

Governors should also establish how decisions relating to staffing, budgets, curriculum, policies and school improvement will be made if the conversion does go ahead.

Finance

The financial health of the MAT is another hugely important area to consider, and schools should make sure they thoroughly review its accounts and future plans to establish whether it is in a strong position before going ahead with any merger.

Economies of scale are another area to consider. Often cited as one of the main benefits of joining a MAT, schools should spend time assessing whether the merger of shared functions such as HR and Finance will offer genuine savings vs their current expenditure. 

Leaders should also be clear on important factors such as how much of the school’s funding will be retained centrally, what services it will cover and how budgets will be allocated moving forwards.

Employees

Converting to academy status and joining a MAT has a number of implications for staff too. When a maintained school converts to an academy and joins a MAT, employees will transfer to the MAT under the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations (TUPE), which protect their existing employment rights and terms and conditions.

Schools and MATs will need to review existing employment arrangements and identify any outstanding disputes, disciplinary matters, grievances or potential claims, as responsibility for employment liabilities will generally transfer to the MAT. Pension obligations must also be considered, including requirements relating to the Teachers’ Pension Scheme and Local Government Pension Scheme.

Alongside legal requirements, schools should consider how the move will affect staff in practice. Will existing leadership and management structures remain in place? What opportunities will there be for professional development? How will staff be supported through the transition?

Contracted Services

Another important consideration is how operational and support services such as ICT, finance, HR and estates management will be delivered. Schools need to understand whether these functions will be managed centrally by the MAT or if they will continue to have responsibility for some services. Services currently provided by the local authority may not be offered to the academy sector and will therefore terminate on conversion, these will need to be identified and contingencies put in place to allow for continuity of provision following conversion.  

Existing contracts for outsourced services such as catering, cleaning, utilities, IT systems and facilities management will also need to be reviewed as some may transfer to the academy trust through a Commercial Transfer Agreement, whilst others may need to be renegotiated or terminated.  

All existing agreements should be reviewed to identify any contractual restrictions, outstanding liabilities, notice periods and potential termination costs. This is particularly important where the MAT already has trust-wide contracts in place and intends to bring the school into those arrangements.

Property and land

Another key area to look at is property and land, as ownership and occupation arrangements can be complex and may affect how quickly a conversion can proceed. Schools should start by establishing who owns their land and buildings and understanding what arrangements will need to be made to allow the academy trust to occupy and use them.

Community schools typically operate under a long-term lease from the local authority following conversion, while foundation, voluntary aided and church schools may require more complex arrangements involving trustees, foundations or diocesan bodies. Existing leases, licences and shared-use agreements should be reviewed, alongside any restrictions affecting school land.

Other issues to consider include rights of way, sports facilities that are used by the local community, caretaker accommodation, third-party occupation and any Private Finance Initiative (PFI) contracts.

Any unresolved land or property issues can significantly delay the conversion process, so it is important to identify these at an early stage.

The legal Journey

The exact legal process of converting to an academy and joining an MAT will depend on the type of school involved and its current status. 

Community schools will need to begin by obtaining necessary approvals and consulting with relevant stakeholders such as staff, parents and other interested parties.

Depending on the type of school, consent or involvement may also be required from the local authority, diocese, foundation or trustees. Schools must also consider their responsibilities under the Equality Act 2010, including whether the proposed changes could have a disproportionate impact on particular groups.

The next stage will then involve putting the necessary legal agreements in place. For maintained schools converting into a MAT, these will typically include a Supplemental Funding Agreement, setting out the terms under which the academy will operate and receive funding from the Department of Education, alongside the MAT’s Master Funding Agreement. A Commercial Transfer Agreement will also usually be required to deal with the transfer of assets, contracts and liabilities, together with the necessary staff transfer arrangements and property documentation.

Joining a MAT can have many benefits but it is not a decision that should be rushed into or based solely on financial gains. Taking proper advice at the outset to ensure all bases are covered can be equally as important as ensuring vision, values and expectations are clearly aligned, in order to ensure any change will deliver real educational benefits and help them to achieve their long-term objectives.